Lifestyle
At 65, She Passed on Her Former Employer’s Cheaper Medicare Advantage Plans. Now 67 and Facing a Heart Valve Replacement: “I Am Not Going to Have to Pay for Any of That”
By Curtis Jones · November 17, 2026
“I am 67, and at 65, I had to make a lot of decisions about what to do for my health care.”
That is how Rhonda opens a video on her YouTube channel, Joyfully Ever After with Rhonda (@JoyfullyEverAfterwithRhonda). She lives in Florida and retired from Disney, which offered her several Medicare Advantage plans through its retiree coverage.
Her first instinct was to take one. The plans were low cost, she says, and came with extras like gym memberships and some vision or dental coverage. Then she sat down with an insurance advisor and weighed what she would be trading. Most of the Advantage options, she says, meant staying in a network and getting approvals before some care.
The other route was Original Medicare, Parts A and B, plus a Medicare Supplement policy, also called Medigap. She chose a Plan G.
“When I started looking at standard Medicare, Part A, Part B, and then a Medicare gap plan, I was like, oh, this is going to cost more money, significantly more money,” she says. “But what I realized was that I would have my choice to go anywhere that accepts Medicare.”
She says that this year, once she paid $283, everything else was covered. She pays her monthly premium and, in her words, never takes out her wallet again.
This past year, her costs went up. She says her Medigap premium and her drug plan were both rising, and the employer’s Advantage plan looked better than ever. It included drugs and could cover her husband.
She called her advisor, who agreed it would be cheaper but pointed to what she would give up, including possibly never getting back into a Medigap plan if she needed one.
“My husband and I thought long and hard about it and you know what? She was right,” Rhonda says. “But I was letting that low price tag dangle in front of me when I was going to be giving up more than I was going to be getting.”
She kept her Medigap plan. “So recently I had a heart catheterization and I’m going to have to have a valve replaced,” she says. “And guess what? I am not going to have to pay for any of that out of my pocket.”
Rhonda stresses that she is not a professional, and that if finances force price to be a factor, people have to decide what is best for them. Here is how the two options compare, according to Medicare.gov.
With Original Medicare, you can use any doctor or hospital that takes Medicare anywhere in the U.S., and in most cases you don’t need prior authorization. But there is no yearly limit on out-of-pocket costs unless you have supplemental coverage like Medigap. Medicare Advantage plans may have a $0 premium, most include drug coverage, and they have a yearly out-of-pocket limit, but you may need to use the plan’s network and get prior authorization for certain services.
The $283 Rhonda mentions matches the 2026 Part B deductible listed on Medicare.gov.
Timing matters with Medigap. Medicare.gov says your Medigap Open Enrollment Period lasts six months, starting the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. During that window, insurers can’t use medical underwriting or deny you over pre-existing conditions. Outside it, you may pay more, and an insurer can deny you if you don’t meet its underwriting requirements, unless you have a guaranteed issue right in certain situations. Your State Insurance Department can tell you whether your state adds protections.
Medicare’s annual Open Enrollment Period runs October 15 to December 7, with changes taking effect January 1.
This article is for general information and is not medical, insurance or financial advice. Rhonda’s story and quotes are from her YouTube video. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.