Lifestyle
Living Alone at 63 on a Fixed Income, She Pays $593 a Month for Her 106-Year-Old House. Sell It and Rent? “Where Would I Go?”
By Erica Coleman · November 18, 2026
She calls it her dumb house, and she means it as a compliment.
“I call this place my dumb house. Not because it was a dumb decision, but because it was the opposite of a smart house,” says the woman behind the YouTube channel @RedDirtRetirement. Her home is in Oklahoma.
She opens the video with the comparison that matters to her. “You could rent a one-bedroom apartment in my town for $735 a month. Or you could rent a house for 12 to 1500. I live in a 106-year-old house that costs me $593 a month total. And no, that’s not a typo.”
She bought the house in 2017 for $48,500. She is 63 now and lives there by herself. She admits she has moved a lot in her life, and the itch came back fast.
“After about a year in this house, I got the urge again,” she says. She called her son and told him she was thinking about moving. “And without missing a beat, he said, ‘Mom, you need to find another hobby.’”
He was right, she says. “This house, this old dumb house, is the best financial decision I’ve made in a long time, even if my feet got itchy.”
Then she walks through the math. “My mortgage, and that includes my taxes and insurance, is $377.33 a month,” she says. “Now, I know some of you are thinking, wait, you still have a mortgage in retirement? And yes, I do.” Electric runs about $97 a month, gas about $55, and water, sewer and trash $63.75.
She keeps repair costs down by doing the work herself. She says she painted the exterior for about $600 in materials and redid the floors for around $1,000 to $1,200. “I’m telling you this because on $1,871 a month, doing the work yourself isn’t a hobby. It’s a survival strategy.”
There is a catch, and she doesn’t hide it. “I need a new roof,” she says. “I’m looking at somewhere between four to six thousand dollars out of my pocket after the insurance. That’s a big number. I’m not going to pretend it isn’t. On a fixed income, four to six thousand dollars is not something you just shrug off.”
She says spreading the high end over the life of a roof still keeps her under $625 a month. When the urge to move hits, she runs the numbers. “Where would I go? A one bedroom apartment at $735 minimum, a rental house at 1200 plus. I’d be paying more every single month for less space, less privacy, less independence.”
Her verdict: “My life doesn’t feel smaller because I live in an old house on a fixed income. If anything, it feels more mine than it ever has.”
Her numbers line up with a bigger picture. According to Harvard’s Joint Center for Housing Studies, 58 percent of renters age 65 and older were cost burdened in 2023, meaning they paid more than 30 percent of their income for housing. The center also found that older owners with a mortgage are more likely to struggle than those who own free and clear, 43 percent versus 19 percent.
Weighing an older home against renting? Add up every monthly housing cost, including taxes, insurance and utilities, and compare it with real rents near you. Price out big repairs you know are coming and divide them over their expected life. Set aside a repair fund before the bill arrives, which she calls her “sleep well at night money.”
This article is for general information and is not financial advice. Her story and quotes are from her YouTube videos. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.