Lifestyle
Nearly 70, She Rented in The Villages, America’s Biggest 55+ Community, for 2 1/2 Years. Would She Live in One Again? “Absolutely Not”
By Erica Coleman · November 19, 2026
For a lot of people nearing retirement, a 55+ community sounds like the answer. Built-in friends, endless activities, and neighbors at the same stage of life.
Kimberly, who runs the YouTube channel Pretty Over Fifty, tried it in the biggest one she knows. “As many of you know I lived in the villages, which is the largest over 55 community in the United States, for over two and a half years,” she told viewers in an August video.
Near the end of the video she mentions her age. “I’ll be 70 in a couple of months,” she said. “I’m really looking forward to my 70s.”
She did not buy. She visited a friend who lived in The Villages in Central Florida, liked what she saw, and rented a house on that first trip. She stayed longer than she planned.
“Did I have fun living in the villages? The answer is I had a flippin’ blast,” she said. “It was like summer camp for a 60-something year old woman.”
She gives the place a lot of credit. She found it well run and very safe as a single woman living alone, and she says the company had things cleaned up quickly after hurricanes. She describes nightly live music in the town squares, residents riding golf carts to meet friends, and what she believes is roughly 400 clubs. If you get bored there, she says, it is because you have not left your house.
So her answer to the big question surprised her own viewers. “Would I live in the villages or any 55 community again? And the answer is emphatically, no, absolutely not.”
Her reason is about her, she says, more than the place. “It is not ultimately, in a long-term way, a good fit for me. Why? Because I don’t live a conventional life.”
She has worked for herself for most of her life and has moved often. She told viewers she wants variety, and the planned setting wore on her. “It’s almost a Truman Show experience,” she said. “In other words, things are too managed. They’re too curated.” She is careful to call this her opinion, and tells residents who love it, “You do you.” She also missed living around people of all ages. Today she lives next door to a young family whose little girls color and crochet with her.
Much of her fun, she said, happened outside the community, kayaking the springs of Central Florida. “Again, I had a great time there. Would I do it again? No, I wouldn’t.”
The Villages is growing fast. The U.S. Census Bureau reported that the Wildwood-The Villages metro area, “known for its large retirement community,” was the nation’s fastest-growing metro area from 2022 to 2023, rising nearly 5% to 151,565 people.
If you are weighing a 55+ community, it helps to know what the label means. Under federal fair housing rules, a community can be age-restricted if it is intended for people 55 and older and at least 80 percent of its occupied units have at least one resident who is 55 or older. That means some residents can be younger, and each community sets its own rules on top of that.
Her experience points to a low-risk way to test the idea. Renting first, as she did, lets you live with the rules, the fees and the social life before you sell a home. She also urged viewers to be honest about who they are, and whether a structured routine feels comforting or suffocating.
This article is for general information only and is not financial, legal or real estate advice. The views quoted are the creator’s own. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.