Light Wave

Lifestyle

She Thought Her 120-Year-Old St. Augustine House Was Her Forever Home. Then the Insurance Renewal Came: “It Can’t Be My Forever Home if I Can’t Afford It”

By Erica Coleman · November 16, 2026

Susan Gregory had settled into a historic two-bedroom house in St. Augustine’s Abbott Tract district, and she planned to stay for good.

Then her homeowners insurance renewal arrived, and she had one word for it. “Ludicrous” is how she described the bill to First Coast News reporter Renata Di Gregorio in June 2023.

“I thought this was my forever home,” Gregory said. “It can’t be my forever home if I can’t afford it.”

Her trouble started with a company she never chose. Her insurer, United Property and Casualty, went insolvent earlier that year, and her policy was taken over by a new company, Slide, according to the station. When the renewal came, her premium had gone from $8,800 to almost $36,000, more than 300 percent higher than what she used to pay.

She did the math on what that money could do instead. “For that amount of money, I could replace my roof,” she said. “I could do all kinds of improvements on my house that would actually make it safer from hurricanes and storms.”

Gregory told the station her home has never flooded. But it is 120 years old, and its roof is original. Those two facts are likely the reason for the jump, according to Jacksonville insurance agent Matthew Carlucci Jr., who told First Coast News the renewal was 12 times what it should be. He said his clients who had been with UPC were getting renewals from Slide that were up to 300 percent more costly.

His advice was not to panic. “The good news is they can typically have their agent get them a policy with another company for a lower premium,” he said. “There’s just not a lot of companies on the market that are aggressively taking on new customers.”

Gregory took that route and asked an agent to shop around. Still, she told the station that some of her neighbors ended up paying their expensive bills, and she worries about what comes next.

“My house, which I wanted to stay in forever, is also my biggest asset,” she said. “If I can’t insure that or if I have to pay $36,000 a year to insure it, then I will quickly be bankrupt. I can’t afford that.”

First Coast News reported that Florida lawmakers passed several reforms in the year before her story aired, but the changes did not promise lower rates. The station said it tried several times to reach Slide and did not hear back.

If a renewal like hers lands in your mailbox, Florida has free help. The Florida Department of Financial Services runs an Insurance Consumer Helpline at 1-877-693-5236, and its Shopping for Homeowners Insurance guide walks through comparing coverage, deductibles and premium discounts. The department points homeowners to the Florida Market Assistance Plan, a free service at fmap.org that can help find coverage, and to its online licensee search for finding a licensed agent in your county.

If you believe an insurer handled a premium, cancellation or nonrenewal improperly, the department says to contact the company first and keep detailed records. If that doesn’t resolve it, you can submit a concern through its Consumer Assistance Portal, and the department says insurers have 14 days to respond once a concern is filed.

Homeowners in other states can contact their state insurance department, which typically offers a similar consumer line. For an older home, ask your agent which updates, such as a new roof, might lower your premium, and get any quote in writing before you commit.

This article is for general information and is not financial or legal advice. Susan Gregory’s story and quotes are from First Coast News’ June 2023 report and video by Renata Di Gregorio; consumer help details are as stated by the Florida Department of Financial Services. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.