Lifestyle
Retired at 57, Five Years Early, He Started Counting the Money He’d “Left on the Table.” Then His Old Journal Changed His Mind
By Mike Harper · November 19, 2026
“So I retired at 57, five years earlier than planned,” Scott says at the start of a video on his YouTube channel, @RetirementUnscriptedScott. At first, he says, he was “really, really, really happy.”
That feeling lasted about two years. Then the math started nagging at him. “I started to have some regrets, primarily around money. I started looking at how much money I’d left on the table. I mean, five years worth. That was a big number, a very big number.”
His original plan was to work to 62, which he calls “the sweet spot.” He lays out what those five years would have bought. “That would have put me right into social security. It would have added five years to my pension… It would have given me a full HSA account, which would have funded me through up until Medicare kicked in.”
He had his reasons. “I was starting to have stress in my life to the point where I had Bell’s palsy. I couldn’t sleep, I was gaining weight. I was drinking too much,” he says. “And so I made the leap and it was the best thing I ever did.”
Early on he golfed, exercised and lost weight, and the household spent less without dry cleaning, lunches out and commuting gas. “There was a lot of expenses to working and all of those went away,” he says.
Life did not follow the script. His mother, one of the reasons he retired, died the month after the pandemic hit, before he had a chance to help her downsize. He stayed busy and kept saving, but that fed the doubts: if he was putting in that much effort, he could have kept working. “Not that we needed the money, but I was thinking, man, that’s a lot of money I left on the table.” Maybe, he thought, “I should have held on.”
He took the regrets to his therapist. “And what she said I should do is go back to my journal to look at why I decided to retire in the first place,” he says.
Reading those old entries brought back what time had softened. “And when you look back, sometimes things seem, oh, you know, they weren’t that bad, but they really were,” he says. “All of the things that led me to retire and be happy about it started coming back.”
The journal also showed him he had drifted from the plan he wrote for retirement itself, so he refocused on what he wanted to do with his time.
His advice: keep a journal, even a paragraph a day. If you’re getting ready to retire, write down why, including the negatives, and write down what you plan to do. “So you can revisit those notes and they will come in handy at a point in time,” he says.
The Social Security Administration says retirement benefits can start as early as 62, but they are reduced for each month before full retirement age. For anyone born in 1960 or later, full retirement age is 67, and claiming at 62 cuts the benefit by about 30%.
Health coverage is the other big gap. Medicare generally starts at 65. The IRS explains in Publication 969 that money in a health savings account stays with you after you leave a job, and withdrawals may be tax free when used for qualified medical expenses. Starting with the first month you are enrolled in Medicare, you can no longer contribute.
Before leaving early, ask how extra working years would change your pension, check your Social Security estimate at ssa.gov, and price health coverage for each year before 65.
This article is for general information and is not financial advice. Scott’s story and quotes are from his YouTube video. This article was produced with the assistance of AI and fact-checked against the sources cited by LightWave Reports.